| Platinum | Fired Up |
| Gold | The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza |
| Silver | Wagon Wheel Pizza |
| Bronze | Pherrara's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Big Romans |
| Top Pick | Bizzarro Pizza |
| Top Pick | Doghouse Piza |
| Top Pick | Mimmo's Restaurant and Pizza |
| Top Pick | Palermo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Papa Johns Pizza |