| Platinum | Woody's Bar-B-Q |
| Gold | Jersey Brothers Diner |
| Silver | The Broken Barrel Tavern |
| Bronze | Twisty Cone Ice Cream & Cakes |
| Top Pick | Copper Chimney |
| Top Pick | Dottie's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Izzy's Diner |
| Top Pick | Rooney's |
| Top Pick | Siggy's-An American Bar |
| Top Pick | Somers Sunshine Cafe |