| Platinum | Keke's Breakfast Cafe |
| Gold | Jersey Brothers Diner |
| Silver | Family Tradition Cafe |
| Bronze | Somers Sunshine Cafe |
| Top Pick | Cocina Cafe |
| Top Pick | Dottie's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Einstein Bros Bagels |
| Top Pick | Lulus Fresh Corner |
| Top Pick | That Little Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Twisted Biscuit |