| Platinum | Shells of Melbourne |
| Gold | Seafood Station |
| Silver | Melbourne Seafood Station |
| Bronze | Crafty Crab |
| Top Pick | Grills Riverside Seafood Deck & Tiki Bar |
| Top Pick | Islands Fish Grill |
| Top Pick | Lazy Turtle Riverfront Grill & Tiki Bar |
| Top Pick | New England Eatery and Pub |
| Top Pick | Old Fish House |