| Platinum | Trattoria Bella |
| Gold | Mimmo's Restaurant and Pizza |
| Silver | Amicis Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria |
| Silver | The Italian Fisherman |
| Bronze | Pizza Viola |
| Top Pick | Bizzarro Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pane E Vino Italian Restaurant, Deli & Bakery |
| Top Pick | The Italian Princess Bakery and Deli |